(A) Purpose
The purpose of this rule is to describe in detail
and provide the format for the information that must be included in a proxy
statement.
(B) Authority
This rule is promulgated pursuant to the
authority vested in the superintendent under sections 3901.041 and 3901.31 of
the Revised Code.
(C) Revocability of proxy
State whether the person giving the proxy has the
power to revoke it. If the right of revocation before the proxy is exercised is
limited, or is subject to compliance with any formal procedure, briefly
describe such limitation or procedure.
(D) Dissenters' rights of appraisal
Outline briefly any rights of appraisal or
similar rights of dissenters with respect to any matter to be acted upon and
indicate any statutory procedure required to be followed by dissenting security
holders to perfect such rights. Where such rights may be exercised only within
a limited time after the date of adoption of a proposal, the filing of a
charter amendment or other similar act, state whether the person solicited will
be notified of such date.
(E) Persons making the solicitation
(1) Solicitations not
subject to rule 3901-2-12 of the Administrative Code.
(a) If the solicitation is made by the issuer, so state. Give the
name of any director of the issuer who has informed the issuer in writing that
the director intends to oppose any action intended to be taken by the issuer
and indicate the action which the director intends to oppose.
(b) If the solicitation is made otherwise than by the issuer, so
state and give the names of the persons by whom and on whose behalf it is
made.
(c) If the solicitation is not to be made by the use of mail,
describe the methods to be employed. If the solicitation is to be made by
specially engaged employees or paid solicitors, state:
(i) The material features
of any contract or agreement for such solicitation and identify the parties;
and
(ii) The cost or
anticipated cost thereof.
(d) State the names of the persons by whom the cost of
solicitation has been or will be borne, directly or indirectly.
(2) Solicitations subject
to rule 3901-2-12 of the Administrative Code.
(a) State by whom the solicitation is made and describe the
methods employed and to be employed to solicit security holders.
(b) If regular employees of the issuer or any other participant
in a solicitation have been or are to be employed to solicit security holders,
describe the class or classes of employees to be so employed and the manner and
nature of their employment for such purpose.
(c) If specially engaged employees, representatives, or other
persons have been or are to be employed to solicit security holders,
state:
(i) The material features
of any contract or arrangement for such solicitation and identify the
parties;
(ii) The cost or
anticipated cost thereof; and
(iii) The approximate
number of such employees or employees of any other person (naming such other
person) who will solicit security holders.
(d) State the total amount estimated to be spent and the total
expenditures to date for, in furtherance of, or in connection with, the
solicitation of security holders.
(e) State by whom the cost of the solicitation will be borne. If
reimbursement will be sought from the issuer, state whether the question of
such reimbursement will be submitted to a vote of security
holders.
(f) If any such solicitation is terminated pursuant to a
settlement between the issuer and any other participant in such solicitation,
describe the terms of such settlement, including the cost or anticipated cost
thereof to the issuer.
(F) Interest of certain persons in matters to be acted
upon.
(1) Solicitations not
subject to rule 3901-2-12 of the Administrative Code.
Describe briefly any substantial interest,
direct or indirect, of each of the following persons in any matter to be acted
upon, other than elections to office:
(a) If the solicitation is made on behalf of the issuer, each
current director or officer of the issuer.
(b) If the solicitation is made otherwise than on behalf of the
issuer, any person who would be a participant in a solicitation (except the
issuer, officer, director, or nominee of the issuer).
(c) Each nominee for election as a director of the
issuer.
(d) Each associate of the foregoing persons.
(2) Solicitations subject
to rule 3901-2-12 of the Administrative Code.
Describe briefly any substantial interest,
direct or indirect, of each participant (except the issuer) in any matter to be
acted upon at the meeting and include, with respect to each participant, the
information or an adequate summary thereof, required by paragraphs (D)(1),
(D)(3), (E), (F)(2), and (F)(3) of rule 3901-2-14 of the Administrative
Code.
(G) Voting securities and principal holders thereof.
(1) State as to each
class of voting securities of the issuer entitled to be voted at the meeting,
the number of shares outstanding and the number of votes to which each class is
entitled.
(2) Give the date as of
which the record of security holders entitled to vote at the meeting will be
determined. If the right to vote is not limited to security holders of record
on that date, indicate the conditions under which other security holders may be
entitled to vote.
(3) If action is to be
taken with respect to the election of directors and if the persons solicited
have cumulative voting rights:
(a) Make a statement that they have such rights;
(b) Describe such rights;
(c) State the conditions precedent to the exercise thereof;
and
(d) If discretionary authority to cumulate votes is solicited, so
indicate.
(4) Furnish security
ownership information as of the most recent practicable date, in substantially
the tabular form set forth in appendix I to this rule, with respect
to:
(a) Any person or group of persons who is known to be the
beneficial owner of more than five per cent of any class of securities;
and
(b) All directors and nominees, naming them, and directors and
officers of the issuer as a group, without naming them.
(5) If, to the knowledge
of the persons on whose behalf the solicitation is made, a change in control of
the issuer has occurred since the beginning of its last fiscal year, state the
name of the person(s) who acquired control, the amount and the source of the
consideration used by such person or persons, the basis of the control, the
date, a description of the transaction(s) which resulted in the change of
control, and the percentage of voting securities of the issuer now beneficially
owned, directly or indirectly, by the person(s) who acquired control and the
identity of the person(s) from whom control was assumed. Describe any
arrangements which may at a subsequent date result in a change of control of
the issuer.
(H) Directors and executive officers.
If action is to be taken with respect to election
of directors, furnish the following information, in tabular form to the extent
practicable, with respect to each person nominated for election as a director
and each person whose term of office will continue after the meeting. If the
solicitation is made on behalf of persons other than the issuer, the
information required need be furnished only as to nominees of the persons
making the solicitation.
(1) Identification of
directors and officers. List the names and ages of all directors and officers
of the issuer and all persons nominated or chosen to become directors or
officers; indicate all positions and offices with the issuer held by each such
person; state such person's term of office as director or officer and any
period(s) during which such person has served as such; briefly describe any
arrangement or understanding between such person and any other person or
persons, naming such person(s), pursuant to which such person was or is to be
selected as a director, officer, or nominee.
(2) Information furnished
in issuer's annual report. The information regarding officers need not be
furnished in proxy or information statements provided that such information is
furnished in a separate item in the issuer's annual report to
stockholders.
(3) Family relationships.
State the nature of any family relationship not more remote than first cousin
between any director, officer, or person nominated or chosen by the issuer to
become a director or officer, and any such family relationship between any such
person and any officer or director of any of the issuer's parents,
subsidiaries, or other affiliates.
(4) Business experience.
State the principal occupations and employment during the past five years of
each director or officer and each person nominated or chosen to become a
director or officer and the name and principal business of any corporation or
other organization in which such occupations and employment were carried
on.
(5) Directorships.
Indicate other directorships held by each director or person nominated or
chosen to become a director.
(6) Involvement in
certain legal proceedings. Describe any legal proceedings that have occurred
during the past five years or which are pending that are material to an
evaluation of the ability or integrity of any director, or person nominated to
become a director or officer of the issuer.
(7) Describe any of the
following relationships which exist.
(a) If the nominee or director is, or has within the last two
full fiscal years been, an officer, director, or employee of, or owns, or has
within the last two fiscal years owned, directly or indirectly, in excess of a
one per cent equity interest in any firm, corporation, or other business or
professional entity:
(i) Which has made
payments to the issuer or its subsidiaries during the issuer's last full
fiscal year or which proposes to make payments to the issuer or its
subsidiaries during the current fiscal year in excess of one per cent of the
issuer's consolidated gross revenues for its last full fiscal
year;
(ii) To which the issuer
or its subsidiaries were indebted at any time during the issuer's last
fiscal year in an aggregate amount in excess of one per cent of the
issuer's total consolidated assets at the end of such fiscal
year;
(iii) To which the issuer
or its subsidiaries have made payments during such entity's last fiscal
year or to which the issuer or its subsidiaries propose to make payments during
such entity's current fiscal year in excess of one per cent of such
entity's consolidated gross revenues for its last full fiscal
year;
(iv) To determine whether
payments made or proposed to be made exceed one per cent of the consolidated
gross revenues of any entity, other than the issuer for such entity's last
full fiscal year, it is appropriate to rely on information provided by the
nominee or director;
(v) In calculating
payments for property and services the following may be excluded:
(a) Payments where the
rates or charges involved in the transaction are determined by competitive bids
or the transaction involves the rendering of services as a public utility at
rates or charges fixed in conformity with law or governmental
authority;
(b) Payments which arise
solely from the ownership of securities of the issuer and no extra or special
benefit not shared on a pro rata basis by all holders of the class of
securities is received.
(vi) In calculating
indebtedness for purposes of paragraph (H)(7)(a)(ii) of this rule, debt
securities which have been publicly offered, admitted to trading on a national
securities exchange, or quoted in the automated quotation system of a
registered securities association may be excluded.
(b) If the nominee or director is a member, employee of, or is
associated with a law firm which the issuer has retained in the last two full
fiscal years or proposes to retain in the current fiscal year where fees paid
or anticipated to be paid by the issuer are material to either the law firm,
the issuer, or both.
(c) If the nominee or director is a director, partner, officer,
or employee of any investment banking firm which has performed services for the
issuer other than as a participating underwriter in a syndicate in the last two
full fiscal years or which the issuer proposes to have perform services in the
current year.
(d) If the nominee or director is a control person of the issuer
(other than solely as a director of the issuer).
(8) Audit:
(a) State whether the issuer has standing audit, nominating, and
compensation committees of the board of directors, or committees performing
similar functions. If the issuer has such committees, however designated,
identify each committee member, state the number of committee meetings held by
each such committee during the last fiscal year, and describe briefly the
functions performed by such committees.
(b) If the issuer has a nominating or similar committee, state
whether the committee will consider nominees recommended by shareholders and,
if so, describe the procedures to be followed by shareholders in submitting
such recommendations.
(9) State the total
number of meetings of the board of directors (including regularly scheduled and
special meetings) which were held during the last full fiscal year. Name each
incumbent director who during the last full fiscal year attended fewer than
seventy-five per cent of the aggregate of:
(a) The total number of meetings of the board of directors (held
during the period for which he has been a director); and
(b) The total number of meetings held by all committees of the
board on which the incumbent director(s) served (during the periods that the
incumbent director(s) served).
(10) If a director has
resigned or declined to stand for reelection to the board of directors since
the date of the last annual meeting of shareholders because of a disagreement
with the issuer on any matter relating to the issuer's operations,
policies, or practices, and if the director has furnished the issuer with a
letter describing such disagreement and requesting that the matter be
disclosed, the issuer shall state the date of resignation or declination to
stand for reelection and summarize the director's description of the
disagreement. If the issuer believes that the description provided by the
director is incorrect or incomplete, the issuer may include a brief statement
presenting its views on the disagreement.
(11) With respect to
those classes of voting stock which participated in the election of directors
at the most recent meeting at which directors were elected:
(a) State the percentage of shares present at the meeting and
voting or withholding authority to vote in the election of directors;
and
(b) Disclose in tabular format, the percentage of total shares
cast for and withheld from the vote for or, where applicable, cast against,
each nominee, which, respectively, were voted for and withheld from the vote
for, or voted against, such nominee. When groups of classes or series of
classes vote together in the election of a director or directors, they shall be
treated as a single class for the purpose of the preceding
sentence.
(12) Instructions:
(a) Calculate the percentage of shares present at the meeting and
voting or withholding authority to vote in the election of directors, referred
to in paragraph (H)(11)(a) of this rule, by dividing the total shares cast for
and withheld from the vote for or, where applicable, voted against, the
director in respect of whom the highest aggregate number of shares was cast by
the total number of shares outstanding which were eligible to vote as of the
record date for the meeting.
(b) No information need be given in response to paragraph (H)(11)
of this rule unless, with respect to any class of voting stock (or group of
classes which voted together), five per cent or more of the total shares cast
for and withheld from the votes for or, where applicable, cast against any
nominee were withheld from the vote for or cast against such
nominee.
(c) If an issuer elects less than the entire board of directors
annually, disclosure is required as to all directors if five per cent or more
of the total shares cast for and withheld from the votes for, or, where
applicable, cast against any incumbent director were withheld from, or cast
against the vote for such director at the meeting at which he was most recently
elected.
(d) No information need be given in response to paragraph (H)(11)
of this rule if the issuer has previously furnished to its security holders a
report of the most recent meeting of security holders at which directors were
elected which includes:
(i) A description of each
matter voted upon at the meeting and a statement of the percentage of the
shares voting which were voted for and against each such matter;
and
(ii) The information
which would be called for by paragraph (H)(11) of this rule. If an issuer has
previously furnished such results to its security holders, this fact should be
set forth in a letter accompanying the filing of preliminary proxy materials
with the superintendent of insurance.
(I) Remuneration of directors and officers.
(1) Furnish the following
information if action is to be taken with regard to:
(a) The election of directors;
(b) Any bonus, profit sharing or other remuneration plan,
contract, or arrangement in which any director, nominee for election as a
director, or officer of the issuer will participate;
(c) Any pension or retirement plan in which any such person will
participate; or
(d) The granting or extension to any such person of any options,
warrants or rights to purchase any securities, other than warrants or rights
issued to security holders as such, on a pro rata basis. If the solicitation is
made on behalf of persons other than the issuer, the information required need
be furnished only as to nominees of the person making the solicitation and
associates of such nominees.
(2) Current remuneration.
Furnish the information required below, in substantially the tabular form set
forth in appendix II to this rule, concerning all remuneration of the following
persons and groups for services in all capacities to the issuer and its
subsidiaries during the issuer's last fiscal year, or, in specified
instances, certain prior fiscal years:
(a) Five officers or directors. Each of the five most highly
compensated officers or directors of the issuer as to whom the total
remuneration required to be disclosed in columns C1 and C2 of the table set
forth in appendix II to this rule, would exceed fifty thousand dollars, naming
each such person; and
(b) All officers or directors. All officers and directors of the
issuer as a group, stating the number of persons in the group without naming
them.
(c) Information to be included. Columns C1, C2, and D of the
table set forth in appendix II to this rule should contain, with respect to
each person or group of persons specified in paragraphs (I)(2)(a) and (I)(2)(b)
of this rule, a dollar amount which reflects the total of all items of
remuneration described in the heading to that column including, but not
necessarily limited to, those items set forth in the subparagraphs of that
column.
(i) Column C of the table
set forth in appendix II to this rule shall include all cash and cash
equivalent forms of remuneration received during the fiscal year and all such
amounts accrued during the fiscal year which, with reasonable certainty, will
be distributed or vested in the future.
(ii) Column C1 of the
table set forth in appendix II to this rule shall include salaries, bonuses,
fees, and commissions, including:
(a) All cash remuneration
distributed or accrued in the form of salaries, commissions, bonuses, and fees
for services rendered.
(b) Compensation earned
for services performed in the latest fiscal year even if it is deferred for
future payment.
(c) Payments received in
the latest fiscal year but earned in prior years which were deferred until the
latest year, if such amounts were not shown in an earlier proxy statement or
annual report to stockholders.
(iii) Column C2 of the
table set forth in appendix II to this rule shall include securities, property,
insurance benefits or reimbursements, and personal benefits (perquisites),
including:
(a) The spread between
the acquisition price, if any, and fair market price of securities or property
acquired under any contract, plan, or arrangement.
(b) Cost of any life
insurance premiums, health insurance premiums, and medical reimbursement plans.
Premiums for nondiscriminatory plans generally available to all salaried
employees are excluded.
(c) Personal benefits
(perquisites) not directly related to job performance, excluding benefits
provided on a nondiscriminatory basis, valued on the basis of cost to the
issuer of providing such benefits.
(i) If unreasonable
effort or expense is required to determine the amounts of personal benefits,
they may be omitted if their aggregate value does not exceed ten thousand
dollars for each officer.
(ii) If the amount of
personal benefits exceed ten per cent of the amount of total remuneration, or
twenty-five thousand dollars, whichever is less, the amount and a brief
description of the benefits must be disclosed in a footnote.
(d) Vested company
contributions to thrift, profit sharing, pension, stock purchase, and similar
plans.
(iv) Column D of the
table set forth in appendix II to this rule shall include all contingent forms
of remuneration, vesting, and measurement of which is subject to future events.
Report only amounts relating to the latest fiscal year, not amounts accrued in
previous periods. Column D shall also include:
(a) The amount expensed
for financial reporting purposes representing nonvested contributions,
payments, or accruals under any pension or retirement plans, annuities,
employment contracts, and deferred compensation plans, including IRS qualified
plans, unless the amount for the individual cannot be separated, in which case
a footnote is required indicating the percentage which contributions to the
plan bear to participants' total remuneration.
(b) The amounts expensed
for financial reporting purposes under any incentive compensation plans
(long-term income plans), such as stock appreciation rights, stock options, and
performance share plans, where the payout is based on objective standards or
stock values. In subsequent years, if the corporation credits compensation
expense for financial reporting purposes as a result of a decline in the value
of contingent compensation, column D may be reduced by a corresponding amount.
A footnote explaining such action should be included.
(c) The amount expensed
for financial reporting purposes for any nonvested contribution payment or
accrual to stock purchase plans, profit sharing, and thrift plans whether or
not they are qualified under the Internal Revenue Code.
(d) Transactions with third parties. Paragraph (I)(2) of this
rule, among other things, includes transactions between the issuer and a third
party when the primary purpose of the transaction is to furnish remuneration to
the persons specified in paragraph (I)(2) of this rule. Other transactions
between the issuer and third parties in which persons specified in paragraph
(I)(2) of this rule have an interest, or may realize a benefit, generally are
addressed by other disclosure requirements concerning the interest of
management and others in certain transactions. Paragraph (I)(2) of this rule
does not require disclosure of remuneration paid to a partnership in which any
officer or director was a partner; any such transaction should be disclosed
pursuant to these other disclosure requirements and not as a note to the
remuneration table set forth in appendix II to this rule presented pursuant to
paragraph (I)(2) of this rule.
(e) Other permitted disclosure. The issuer may provide additional
disclosure through a footnote to the table set forth in appendix II to this
rule, through additional columns, or otherwise describing the components of
aggregate renumeration in such greater detail as is appropriate.
(3) Proposed
remuneration:
(a) Briefly describe all remuneration payments proposed to be
made in the future, pursuant to any existing plan or arrangement to the persons
and groups specified in paragraph (I)(2) of this rule. As to defined benefit or
actuarial plans with respect to which amounts are not included in the table set
forth in appendix II to this rule, include a separate table showing the
estimated annual benefits payable upon retirement to persons in specified
remuneration and years-of-service classification.
(b) Information need not be furnished with respect to any group
life, health, hospitalization, or medical reimbursement plans which do not
discriminate in favor of officers or directors of the issuer and which are
available generally to all salaried employees.
(4) Remuneration of
directors. Describe any standard or special arrangements, stating amounts, by
which directors of the issuer are compensated for services as a
director.
(5) Options, warrants, or
rights:
(a) Furnish the information required by the table set forth in
appendix III to this rule as to all options to purchase securities from the
issuer or its subsidiaries which were granted to or exercised by the persons
and groups specified in paragraph (I)(2) of this rule since the beginning of
the issuer's last fiscal year, and as to all options held by such persons
as of the latest practicable date.
(b) The information included in the table set forth in appendix
III to this rule will show as to each director, officer, and as to all
directors and officers as a group:
(i) The amount of options
granted since the beginning of the issuer's last full fiscal
year;
(ii) The amount of shares
acquired since the date through the exercise of options;
(iii) The amount of
shares of the same class sold during such period; and
(iv) The amount of shares
subject to all unexercised options held as of the most recent practicable
date.
(c) Instructions:
(i) All figures should be
adjusted, where applicable, in accordance with the terms of the options to
reflect stock splits and to give effect to share dividends.
(ii) Other tabular
presentations are acceptable if they include the necessary data. Tabular
presentation may not be needed if only a limited number of options have been
granted.
(iii) Total market
value:
(a) Where the total
market value on the granting dates of the securities called for by all options
granted during the period specified does not exceed ten thousand dollars for
any officer or director named in answer to paragraph (I)(2) of this rule, or
forty thousand dollars for all officers and directors as a group, this item
need not be answered with respect to options granted to such person or
group.
(b) Where the total
market value on the dates of purchase of all securities purchased through the
exercise of options during the period specified does not exceed ten thousand
dollars for any such person or forty thousand dollars for such group, this item
need not be answered with respect to options exercised by such person or
group.
(c) Where the total
market value as of the latest practicable date of the securities called for by
all options held at such time does not exceed ten thousand dollars for any such
person or forty thousand dollars for such group, this item need not be answered
with respect to options held as of the specified date by such person or
group.
(d) The term
"options" as used in paragraph (I)(5) of this rule includes all
options, warrants, or rights, other than those issued to security holders as
such on a pro rata basis. Where the average option price per share is called
for, the weighted average price per share shall be given.
(e) The extension,
regranting or material amendment of options is deemed the granting of options
within the meaning of paragraph (I)(5) of this rule.
(f) If the options relate
to more than one class of securities, the information shall be given separately
for each such class.
(6) Indebtedness of
management.
(a) State as to each of the following persons who was indebted to
the issuer or its subsidiaries at any time since the beginning of the last
fiscal year of the issuer:
(i) The largest aggregate
amount of indebtedness outstanding at any time during such period;
(ii) The nature of the
indebtedness outstanding and the transaction in which it was
incurred;
(iii) The amount thereof
outstanding as of the latest practicable date; and
(iv) The rate of interest
paid or charged thereon:
(a) Each director or
officer of the issuer;
(b) Each nominee for
election as a director; and
(c) Each associate of any
such director, officer, or nominee.
(b) Paragraph (I)(6) of this rule does not apply to:
(i) Any person whose
aggregate indebtedness did not exceed ten thousand dollars or one per cent of
the issuer's total assets, whichever is less, at any time during the
period specified; or
(ii) Indebtedness under
an insurance policy.
(7) Transactions with
management.
(a) Describe briefly any transaction since the beginning of the
issuer's last fiscal year or any presently proposed transactions, to which
the issuer or any of its subsidiaries was or is to be a party, in which any of
the following persons had or is to have a direct or indirect material interest,
naming such person and stating such person's relationship to the issuer,
the nature of such person's interest in the transaction, and, where
practicable, the amount of such interest:
(i) Any director or
officer of the issuer;
(ii) Any nominee for
election as a director;
(iii) Any security holder
who is known to the issuer to own of record of beneficially more than ten per
cent of any class of the issuer's voting securities; and
(iv) Any relative or
spouse of any of the foregoing persons, or any relative of such spouse, who has
the same home as such person or who is a director or officer of any parent or
subsidiary of the issuer.
(b) Describe briefly any material legal proceedings to which any
such person is a party adverse to the issuer or any of its subsidiaries or has
a material interest adverse to the issuer or any of its
subsidiaries.
(c) No information need be given in response to paragraph (I)(7)
of this rule as to any remuneration or other transaction reported in response
to paragraph (I)(2), (I)(3), (I)(4), (I)(5), or (I)(6) of this rule, or as to
any transaction with respect to which information may be omitted pursuant to
these items.
(d) No information need be given in answer to paragraph (I)(7) of
this rule as to any transaction where:
(i) The rates or charges
involved in the transaction are determined by competitive bids, or at rates or
charges fixed in conformity with law or governmental authority;
(ii) The transaction
involves services as a bank depository of funds, transfer agent, registrar,
trustee under a trust indenture, or similar services;
(iii) The amount involved
in the transactions or series of similar transactions, including all periodic
installments in the case of any lease or other agreement providing for periodic
payments or installments, does not exceed forty thousand dollars;
or
(iv) The interest of the
specified person arises solely from the ownership of securities of the issuer
and the specified person receives no extra or special benefit not shared on a
pro rata basis by all holders of securities of the class.
(e) This item calls for disclosure of indirect, as well as
direct, material interests in transactions. A person who has a position or
relationship with a firm, corporation, or other entity, which engages in a
transaction with the issuer or its subsidiaries, may have an indirect interest
in such transaction by reason of such position or relationship. A person does
not to have a material indirect interest in a transaction within the meaning of
paragraph (I)(7) of this rule where:
(i) The interest arises
only:
(a) From such
person's position as a director of another corporation or organization
(other than a partnership) which is a party to the transaction; or
(b) From the direct or
indirect ownership by such person and all other persons specified in paragraph
(I)(7) of this rule of less than a ten per cent equity interest in another
person (other than a partnership) which is a party to the transaction;
or
(c) From both such
position and ownership.
(ii) The interest arises
only from such person's position as a limited partner in a partnership in
which that person and all other persons specified in paragraph (I)(7) of this
rule had an interest of less than ten per cent; or
(iii) The interest of
such person arises solely from the holding of an equity interest (including a
limited partnership interest but excluding a general partnership interest) or a
creditor interest in another person which is a party to the transaction with
the issuer or any of its subsidiaries and the transaction is not material to
such other person.
(f) Instructions:
(i) In describing any
transactions involving the purchase or sale of assets by or to the issuer or
any of its subsidiaries, otherwise than in the ordinary course of business,
state the cost of the assets to the purchaser and, if acquired by the seller
within two years prior to the transaction, the cost thereof to the seller.
Indicate the principle followed in determining the issuer's purchase or
sale price and the name of the person making such determination.
(ii) Information shall be
furnished in answer to this item with respect to transactions not excluded
above which involve remuneration from the issuer or its subsidiaries, directly
or indirectly, to any of the specified persons for services in any capacity
unless the interest of such persons arises solely from the ownership
individually and in the aggregate of less than ten per cent of any class of
equity securities of another corporation furnishing the services to the issuer
or its subsidiaries.
(8) Transactions with
pension or similar plans:
(a) Describe briefly any transactions since the beginning of the
issuer's last fiscal year, or any presently proposed transactions, to
which any pension, retirement, savings or similar plan provided by the issuer,
or any of its parents or subsidiaries was or is to be a party, in which any of
the persons specified in paragraph (I)(7) of this rule or the issuer or any of
its subsidiaries had or is to have a direct or indirect material interest,
naming such person and stating such person's relationship to the issuer,
the nature of such person's interest in the transaction and, where
practicable, the amount of such interest.
(b) No information need be given in answer to paragraph (I)(8) of
this rule with respect to:
(i) Payments to the plan,
or payments to beneficiaries, pursuant to the terms of the plan;
(ii) Payment of
remuneration for services not in excess of five per cent of the aggregate
remuneration received by the specified person during the issuer's last
fiscal year from the issuer and its subsidiaries; or
(iii) Any interest of the
issuer or any of its subsidiaries which arises solely from its general interest
in the success of the plan.
(c) Instructions:
(i) Paragraph (I)(7)(c)
of this rule applies to paragraph (I)(8) of this rule.
(ii) Without limiting the
general meaning of the term "transaction," include any remuneration
received or any loans received or outstanding during the period, or proposed to
be received.
(J) Matters related to accounting. If the solicitation is made on
behalf of the issuer and relates to an annual meeting of security holders at
which directors are to be elected, or financial statements are included,
furnish the following information:
(1) If the issuer's
financial statements are not certified by independent public or certified
accountants, so state.
(2) If the board of
directors has no audit or similar committee, so state.
(3) If the issuer's
financial statements are certified by independent public or certified
accountants, so state and provide the following information:
(a) The name of the principal accountant selected or being
recommended to shareholders for election, approval, or ratification for the
current year. If no accountant has been elected or recommended, so state and
briefly describe the reason therefor.
(b) The name of the principal accountant for the fiscal year most
recently completed if different from the accountant selected or recommended for
the current year or if no accountant has been elected or recommended for the
current year.
(c) If a change or changes in accountants have taken place since
the date of the proxy statement for the most recent annual meeting of
shareholders, so state, and if in connection with such change(s) a material
disagreement in connection with financial disclosure between the accountant and
issuer has occurred, the disagreement shall be described. Prior to filing the
preliminary proxy materials with the superintendent of insurance which contains
or amends such description, the issuer shall furnish the description of the
disagreement to any accountant with whom the disagreement has occurred. If that
accountant believes that the description of the disagreement is incorrect or
incomplete, the accountant may include a brief statement, not to exceed two
hundred words, in the proxy statement presenting the accountant's view of
the disagreement. This statement shall be submitted to the issuer within ten
business days of the date the accountant receives the issuer's
description.
(d) The proxy statement shall indicate whether representatives of
the principal accountants for the current year and for the most recently
completed fiscal year are expected to be present at the stockholders'
meeting with the opportunity to make a statement if they desire to do so and
whether such representatives are expected to be available to respond to
appropriate questions.
(e) If any change in accountants has taken place since the date
of the proxy statement for the most recent annual meeting of shareholders,
state whether such change was recommended or approved by:
(i) Any audit or similar
committee of the board of directors, if the issuer has such a committee;
or
(ii) The board of
directors, if the issuer has no such committee.
(4) For the fiscal year
most recently completed, describe each professional service provided by the
principal accountant and state the percentage relationship which the aggregate
of the fees for all nonaudit services bear to the audit fees, and, except as
provided in this paragraph, state the percentage relationship which the fee for
each nonaudit service bears to the audit fees. Indicate whether, before each
professional service provided by the principal accountant was rendered, it was
approved by, and the possible effect on the independence of the accountant was
considered by:
(a) Any audit or similar committee of the board of directors;
and
(b) For any service not approved by an audit or similar
committee, the board of directors.
(5) Instructions:
(a) For purposes of paragraph (J) of this rule, all fees for
services provided in connection with the audit function (e.g., reviews of
quarterly reports) may be computed as part of the audit fees. Indicate which
services are reflected in the audit fees computation.
(b) If the fee for any nonaudit services is less than three per
cent of the audit fees, the percentage relationship need not be
disclosed.
(c) Each service should be specifically described. Broad general
categories such as "tax matters" or "management advisory
services" are not sufficiently specific.
(d) Describe the circumstances and give details of any services
provided by the issuer's independent accountant during the latest fiscal
year that were furnished at rates or terms that were not
customary.
(e) Describe any existing direct or indirect understanding or
agreement that places a limit on the current or future years' audit fees,
including fee arrangements that provide fixed limits on fees that are not
subject to reconsideration if unexpected issues involving accounting or
auditing are encountered. Disclosure of fee estimates is not
required.
(K) Bonus, profit sharing, and other remuneration plans; pension
and retirement plans.
If action is to be taken with respect to any
bonus, profit sharing, or other remuneration plan, or any pension or retirement
plan, furnish the following information:
(1) Describe briefly the
material features of the plan, identify each class of persons who will
participate therein, indicate the approximate number of persons in each such
class, and state the basis of such participation.
(2) Furnish such
information, in addition to that required by paragraphs (I) and (K) of this
rule, as may be necessary to describe adequately the provisions already made
pursuant to all bonus, profit sharing, pension, retirement, stock option, stock
purchase, deferred compensation, or other remuneration or incentive plans, now
in effect or in effect within the past five years, for:
(a) Each director or officer named in answer to paragraph (I)(2)
of this rule who may participate in the plan to be acted upon;
(b) All present directors and officers of the issuer as a group,
if any director or officer may participate in the plan; and
(c) All employees, if employees may participate in the
plan.
(3) If the plan to be
acted upon can be amended otherwise than by a vote of stockholders, to increase
the cost thereof to the issuer or to alter the allocation of the benefits as
between the directors and officers on the one hand and employees on the other,
state the nature of the amendments which can be so made.
(4) With regard to any
bonus, profit sharing, or other remuneration plan, on which action is to be
taken, furnish the following information.
(a) State separately the amounts which would have been
distributable under the plan during the last fiscal year of the
issuer:
(i) To directors and
officers; and
(ii) To employees if the
plan had been in effect.
(b) State the name and position with the issuer of each person
specified in paragraph (I)(2) of this rule who will participate in the plan and
the amount which each such person would have received under the plan for the
last fiscal year of the issuer if the plan had been in effect.
(5) With regard to any
pension or retirement plan on which action is to be taken, furnish the
following information:
(a) The approximate total amount necessary to fund the plan with
respect to past services, the period over which such amount is to be paid, and
the estimated annual payments necessary to pay the total amount over such
period;
(b) The estimated annual payments to be made for the benefit
of:
(i) Directors and
officers; and
(ii) Employees.
(c) The name and position with the issuer of each person
specified in paragraph (I)(2) of this rule who will be entitled to participate
in the plan;
(d) The amount which would have been paid or set aside by the
issuer and its subsidiaries for the benefit of such person for the last fiscal
year of the issuer if the plan had been in effect; and
(e) The amount of the annual benefits estimated to be payable to
such person in the event of retirement at normal retirement date.
(6) Instructions:
(a) If action is to be taken with respect to the amendment or
modification of an existing plan, the item shall be answered with respect to
the plan as proposed to be amended or modified and indicate any material
differences from the existing plan.
(b) The following instruction applies to paragraph (K)(2) of this
rule:
(i) Information need only
be given with respect to benefits received or set aside within the past five
years.
(ii) Information need not
be included as to payments made for, or benefits to be received from, group
life or accident insurance, group hospitalization or similar group payments or
benefits.
(iii) If action is to be
taken with respect to any plan in which directors or officers may participate,
the information called for by paragraph (I)(5) of this rule shall be furnished
for the last five fiscal years of the issuer and any period subsequent to the
end of the latest such fiscal year, in aggregate amounts for the entire period
for such person and group. If any named person, or any other director or
officer, purchased securities through the exercise of options during such
period, state the aggregate amount of securities of that class sold during the
period by such named person and such other directors and officers as a group.
The information called for by these instructions is in lieu of the information
since the beginning of the issuer's last fiscal year called for by
paragraph (I)(5) of this rule. If employees may participate in the plan to be
acted upon, state the aggregate amount of securities called for by all options
granted to employees during the five-year period, and if the options were other
than "incentive stock options" or options granted pursuant to an
"employee stock purchase plan," as the quoted terms are defined in
sections 422 to 423 (2017) and 424 (2018) of the Internal Revenue Code, state
that fact and the weighted average option price per share. The information
called for by these instructions may be furnished in the form of the table set
forth in paragraph (I)(5) of this rule.
(c) If the plan to be acted upon is set forth in a written
document, a copy thereof shall be filed with the superintendent of insurance at
the time preliminary copies of the proxy statement and form of proxy are
filed.
(d) The information called for by paragraph (K)(5) of this rule
need not be given as to payments made on an actuarial basis pursuant to any
group pension plan which provides for fixed benefits in the event of retirement
at a specified age or after a specified number of years of
service.
(L) Options, warrants, or rights. If action is to be taken with
respect to the granting or extension of any options to purchase securities of
the issuer or any subsidiary, furnish the following information:
(1) The title and amount
of securities called for or to be called for by such options;
(2) The prices,
expiration dates, and other material conditions upon which the options may be
exercised;
(3) The consideration
received or to be received by the issuer or subsidiary for the granting or
extension of the options;
(4) The market value of
the securities called for or to be called for by the options as of the latest
practicable date; and
(5) In the case of
options, the federal income tax consequences of the issuance and exercise of
such option to the recipient and to the issuer.
(6) State separately the
amount of options received or to be received by the following persons, naming
each such person:
(a) Each director and officer named in answer to paragraph (I)(2)
of this rule;
(b) Each nominee for election as a director of the
issuer;
(c) Each associate of such directors, officers, or nominees;
and
(d) Each other person who received or is to receive ten per cent
or more of such options. State, also, the total amount of such options received
or to be received by all directors and officers of the issuer as a group,
without naming them.
(7) Furnish such
information, in addition to that required by paragraphs (I) and (L) of this
rule as may be necessary to describe adequately the provisions already made
pursuant to all bonus, profit sharing, pension, retirement, stock option, stock
purchase, deferred compensation, or other remuneration or incentive plans, now
in effect or in effect within the past five years, for:
(a) Each director or officer named in answer to paragraph (I)(2)
of this rule who may participate in the plan to be acted upon;
(b) All present directors and officers for the issuer as a group,
if any director or officer may participate in the plan; and
(c) All employees, if employees may participate in the
plan.
(8) Instructions:
(a) For the purpose of paragraph (L) of this rule, the term
"option" includes any option, warrant or right.
(b) Paragraphs (L)(2) and (L)(3) of this rule do not apply to
warrants or rights to be issued to security holders as such on a pro rata
basis.
(c) Paragraph (K)(6)(b) of this rule applies to paragraph (L)(3)
of this rule.
(d) If the options described in answer to paragraph (L) of this
rule are issued pursuant to a plan which is set forth in a written document, a
copy thereof shall be filed with the superintendent of insurance at the time
preliminary copies of the proxy statement and form of proxy are
filed.
(M) Authorization or issuance of securities otherwise than for
exchange.
If action is to be taken with respect to the
authorization or issuance of any securities otherwise than for exchange for
outstanding securities of the issuer, furnish the following information:
(1) State the title and
amount of securities to be authorized or issued.
(2) If the securities are
other than additional shares of common stock of a class outstanding, furnish a
brief summary of the following, if applicable: dividend, voting, liquidation,
preemptive, and conversion rights; redemption and sinking fund provisions; and
interest rate and date of maturity.
(3) Describe briefly the
transaction in which the securities are to be issued, including a statement as
to:
(a) The nature and approximate amount of consideration received
or to be received by the issuer; and
(b) The approximate amount devoted to each purpose, as far as is
determinable, for which the net proceeds have been or are to be used. If it is
impracticable to describe the transaction in which the securities are to be
issued, state the reason, indicate the purpose of the authorization of the
securities, and state whether further authorization for the issuance of the
securities by a vote of security holders will be solicited prior to such
issuance.
(4) If the securities are
to be issued otherwise than in a general public offering for cash, state the
reasons for the proposed authorization or issuance and the general effect
thereof upon the rights of existing security holders.
(N) Modification or exchange of securities.
If action is to be taken with respect to the
modification of any class of securities of the issuer, or the issuance or
authorization for issuance of securities of the issuer in exchange for
outstanding securities of the issuer, furnish the following information:
(1) If the outstanding
securities are to be modified, state the title and amount thereof. If
securities are to be issued in exchange for outstanding securities, state the
title and amount of securities to be so issued, the title and amount of
outstanding securities to be exchanged therefor and the basis of the
exchange.
(2) Describe any material
differences between the outstanding securities and the modified or new
securities.
(3) State the reasons for
the proposed modification or exchange and the general effect thereof upon the
rights of existing security holders.
(4) Furnish a brief
statement as to arrears in dividends or as to defaults in principal or interest
with respect to the outstanding securities which are to be modified or
exchanged and such other information as may be appropriate in the particular
case to disclose adequately the nature and effect of the proposed
action.
(5) Outline briefly any
other material features of the proposed modification or exchange. If the plan
of proposed action is set forth in a written document, file copies thereof with
the superintendent of insurance at the time the preliminary proxy material is
filed.
(O) Mergers, consolidations, acquisitions, and similar
matters.
(1) Furnish the following
information if action is to be taken with respect to any plan for:
(a) The merger or consolidation of the issuer;
(b) The acquisition by the issuer or any of its security holders
of securities of another person;
(c) The acquisition by the issuer of any other going business or
of the assets thereof;
(d) The sale or other transfer of all or any substantial part of
the assets of the issuer; or
(e) The liquidation or dissolution of the issuer.
(2) Outline briefly the
material features of the plan. State the reasons therefor and the general
effect thereof upon the rights of existing security holders. If the plan is set
forth in a written document, file a copy thereof with the superintendent of
insurance at the time preliminary copies of the proxy statement and form of
proxy are filed.
(3) Furnish the following
information as to the issuer and each person which is to be merged into the
issuer or into or with which the issuer is to be merged or consolidated or the
business or assets of which are to be acquired or which is the issuer of
securities to be acquired by the issuer in exchange for all or a substantial
part of its assets or to be acquired by security holders of the issuer. What is
required is information essential to an investor's appraisal of the action
proposed to be taken.
(a) Describe briefly the business of such person.
(b) State the location and describe the general character of the
plants and other important physical properties of such person. The description
is to be given from an economic and business standpoint, as distinguished from
a legal standpoint. Portfolio or investment assets of an issuer need not be
disclosed.
(c) Furnish a brief statement as to dividends in arrears or
defaults in principal or interest in respect of any securities of the issuer or
of such person, and as to the effect of the plan thereon and such other
information as may be appropriate in the particular case to disclose adequately
the nature and effect of the proposed action.
(d) Furnish a tabulation in columnar form showing the existing
and the pro forma capitalization.
(e) Furnish in columnar form for each of the last five fiscal
years an historical summary of earnings and show per-share amounts of net
earnings, dividends declared for each year, and book value per share at the end
of the latest period.
(f) Furnish in columnar form for each of the last five fiscal
years a combined pro forma summary of earnings, as appropriate in the
circumstances, indicating the aggregate and per-share earnings for each such
year and the pro forma book value per share at the end of the latest period. If
the transaction establishes a new basis of accounting for assets of any of the
persons included therein, the pro forma summary of earnings shall be furnished
only for the most recent fiscal year and interim period and shall reflect
appropriate pro forma adjustments resulting from such new basis of
accounting.
(g) To the extent material for the exercise of prudent judgment
in regard to the matter to be acted upon, furnish the historical and pro forma
earnings data specified in paragraphs (G) and (H) of this rule for interim
periods of the current and prior fiscal years, if available.
(4) Instructions:
Paragraphs (O)(2) and (O)(3) of this rule do
not apply if the plan described in answer to paragraph (O)(1) of this rule
involves only the issuer and one or more of its wholly owned subsidiaries. As
to each class of securities of the issuer, or of any person specified in
paragraph (O)(2) of this rule, which is admitted to dealing on a national
securities exchange or with respect to which a market otherwise exists, and
which will be materially affected by the plan, state the high and low sale
prices (or, in the absence of trading in a particular period, the range of the
bid and asked prices) for each quarterly period within two years. This
information may be omitted if the plan involves only the liquidation or
dissolution of the issuer.
(P) Financial statements.
(1) If action is to be
taken with respect to any matter specified in paragraph (M), (N), or (O) of
this rule, financial statements of the issuer and its subsidiaries complying
with the requirements of paragraphs (D)(1), (D)(2), and (D)(3) of rule
3901-2-04 of the Administrative Code shall be furnished, including schedules of
supplementary profit and loss information. Such statements may be omitted with
respect to a plan described in answer to paragraph (O) of this rule if the plan
involves only the issuer and one or more of its wholly owned
subsidiaries.
(2) If action is to be
taken with respect to any matter specified in paragraph (O) of this rule,
furnish for each person specified therein, other than the issuer, financial
statements complying with the requirements of paragraphs (D)(1), (D)(2), and
(D)(3) of rule 3901-2-04 of the Administrative Code.
(3) The superintendent of
insurance may, upon the request of the issuer, permit the omission of any of
the statements herein required where such statements are not necessary for the
exercise of prudent judgment in regard to any matter to be acted upon, or may
permit the filing in substitution therefor of appropriate statements of
comparable character. The superintendent of insurance may also require the
filing of other statements in addition to, or in substitution for, the
statements herein required in any case where such statements are necessary or
appropriate for an adequate presentation of the financial condition of any
person whose financial statements are required, or whose statements are
otherwise material for the exercise of prudent judgment in regard to any matter
to be acted upon. In the usual case, financial statements are deemed material
to the exercise of prudent judgment where the matter to be acted upon is the
authorization or issuance of a material amount of senior securities, but are
not deemed material where the matter to be acted upon is the authorization or
issuance of common stock, otherwise than in an exchange, merger or
consolidation, acquisition, or similar transaction.
(4) The proxy statement
may incorporate by reference any financial statements contained in an annual
report sent to security holders with respect to the same meeting as that to
which the proxy statement relates, provided such financial statements
substantially meet the requirements of this item.
(Q) Acquisition or disposition of property.
If action is to be taken with respect to the
acquisition or disposition of any property, furnish the following
information:
(1) Describe briefly the
general character and location of the property.
(2) State the nature and
amount of consideration to be paid or received by the issuer or any subsidiary.
To the extent practicable, outline briefly the facts bearing upon the question
of the fairness of the consideration.
(3) State the name and
address of the transferor or transferee as the case may be, and the nature of
any material relationship of such person to the issuer or an affiliate of the
issuer.
(4) Briefly outline any
other material features of the contract or transaction.
(R) Restatement of accounts.
If action is to be taken with respect to the
restatement of any asset, capital, or surplus account of the issuer, furnish
the following information:
(1) State the nature of
the restatement and the date as of which it is to be effective.
(2) Briefly outline the
reasons for the restatement and for the selection of the particular effective
date.
(3) State the name and
amount of each account (including any reserve accounts) affected by the
restatement and the effect of the restatement thereon. Tabular presentation of
the amounts shall be made when appropriate, particularly in the case of
recapitalization.
(4) To the extent
practicable, state whether and the extent, if any, to which the restatement
will, as of the date thereof, alter the amount available for distribution to
the holders of equity securities.
(S) Action with respect to reports.
If action is to be taken with respect to any
report of the issuer or of its directors, officers, or committees or any
minutes of meetings of its stockholders, furnish the following
information:
(1) State whether such
action is to constitute approval or disapproval of any of the matters referred
to in such reports or minutes.
(2) Identify each of such
matters which it is intended will be approved or disapproved and furnish the
information required by the appropriate item or items of this schedule with
respect to each such matter.
(T) Matters not required to be submitted.
If action is to be taken with respect to any
matter which is not required to be submitted to a vote of security holders,
state the nature of such matter, the reason for submitting it to a vote of
security holders, and what action is intended to be taken by the management in
the event of a negative vote on the matter by the security holders.
(U) Amendment of charter, bylaws, or other
documents.
(1) If action is to be
taken with respect to any amendment of the issuer's charter, bylaws, or
other documents as to which information is not required by this rule, state
briefly the reasons for and general effect of such amendment.
(2) Where the matter to
be acted upon is the classification of directors, state whether vacancies which
occur during the year may be filled by the board of directors to serve only
until the next annual meeting or may be so filled for the remainder of the full
term.
(V) Other proposed action.
If action is to be taken with respect to any
matter not specifically referred to in this rule, describe briefly the
substance of each such matter in substantially the same degree of detail as is
required by paragraphs (G) to (U) of this rule.
(W) Vote required for approval.
As to each matter which is to be submitted to a
vote of security holders, other than election to office or the selection or
approval of auditors, state the vote required for its approval.
(X) Severability
If any portion of this rule or the application
thereof to any person or circumstance is held invalid, the invalidity does not
affect other provisions or applications of the rule or related rules which can
be given effect without the invalid portion or application, and to this end the
provisions of this rule are severable.
